Is Proof-of-Stake centralising?

Bitget App

Trade smarter

Bitget

News

Cointime2023/12/26 12:41

By:Cointime

from r/CryptoCurrency by pixieshit

Let me preface this by saying that I think decentralised finance is one of the greatest inventions in our lifetimes. To think that all the financial empires of the past few millennia struggled to find monetary media and stores of wealth that was incorruptible, salable, resistant to supply manipulation... and the closest that they ever got was gold... I find crypto exciting and the technology beautiful. I can't wait to see it play out over the next decade.

The value of crypto over fiat is decentralisation. Without decentralisation, crypto would be worthless. So any claims that a consensus mechanism is centralised is a cause for discussion.

I have rudimentary knowledge of how Proof-of-Work and Proof-of-Stake works. In PoW, the network is secured by mining power. In PoS, the network is secured by locked validator funds. I cheered on the 2022 ETH PoW -> PoS merge, even baked lil ethereum-shaped cookies for it haha. To me ETH was just being decentralised in another way, because you would see the same dispersion of validators in a PoS system as you would see of miners in a PoW system. Sure, there would still be degrees of centralisation contingent on how some entities could possess more processing power or a larger stake, but this risk exists for both consensus mechanisms.

However I'm reading a book called Broken Money now by Lyn Alden. She's very pro-bitcoin but argues that PoS blockchains are inherently centralising.

The claims I can make out so far:

PoS requires trust, while BTC/PoW is trustless. She cites both the Solana and BSC blockchain (both PoS) going offline several times during 22-23 (I'm surprised more people aren't concerned about this). Since there is no real-world cost (like committing electricity) to producing new blocks on PoS chains, anyone can create an alternative ledger of false transactions. She argues that the only way to proceed is for major stakers to get into a literal chatroom and decide where to restart a blockchain from - and so systems are dependent on centralised entities, usually those that hold the most wealth.
The rich get richer faster, and increasingly possess more power in the system. The nature of PoS is that staking more coins increases staking yields, which in turn increases the staked funds. This leads to an exponential increase in the share of the network. Theoretically, over time, power centralises to the wealthiest validators.
PoS is inherently concentrating, with limited distributive capability. For reasons stated in the dot point above

Could more tech-savvy weigh-in? How legit are these claims? Is the degree of potential centralisation worrying? Or negligible? Serious answers only, leave the shitposts at the door

So far I haven't seen any problems with how Eth is running (I'm so pro-eth it's not funny) but I wonder if these problems are more salient in smaller PoS blockhains.

Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.

PoolX: Earn new token airdrops

Lock your assets and earn 10%+ APR

Lock now!

The article analyzes the TGE performance of multiple blockchain projects, evaluating project performance using three dimensions: current price versus all-time high, time span, and liquidity-to-market cap ratio. Projects are then categorized into five grades: S, A, B, C, and D. Summary generated by Mars AI This summary was generated by the Mars AI model, and the accuracy and completeness of its content are still being iteratively updated.

MarsBit•2025/11/28 16:26

2025 TGE Survival Ranking: Who Will Rise to the Top and Who Will Fall? Complete Grading of 30+ New Tokens, AVICI Dominates S+

Mars Finance | "Machi" increases long positions, profits exceed 10 million dollars, whale shorts 1,000 BTC

Russian households have invested 3.7 billion rubles in cryptocurrency derivatives, mainly dominated by a few large players. INTERPOL has listed cryptocurrency fraud as a global threat. Malicious Chrome extensions are stealing Solana funds. The UK has proposed new tax regulations for DeFi. Bitcoin surpasses $91,000. Summary generated by Mars AI. The accuracy and completeness of this summary are still being iteratively updated by the Mars AI model.

MarsBit•2025/11/28 16:26