Fed Faces Rate Decision Challenges: Incomplete Data Deepens Policy Disagreements

The U.S. economy is approaching a crucial crossroads next week as it deals with the consequences of a two-month government shutdown and growing disagreements within the Federal Reserve regarding interest rate decisions. With the first non-farm payrolls report since the shutdown about to be published, both policymakers and investors are uncertain if the Fed will proceed with a third rate reduction at its December session.

The shutdown has interrupted the release of essential economic indicators, such as October’s employment and inflation statistics, needed to assess the nation’s economic condition.

Both the White House and Congressional leaders have admitted that the jobs and consumer price index (CPI) figures for October might never be fully published,

and other departments were unable to finish their surveys during the shutdown period. Many economists are calling on the Labor Department to make the release of November’s numbers a priority, so the Fed can have up-to-date information for its December policy review . Without current statistics, the Fed faces the risk of making policy choices based on partial or obsolete information, its evaluation of inflation and employment patterns.

Within the Fed, internal disagreements are becoming more pronounced. Boston Fed President Susan Collins and Atlanta Fed President Raphael Bostic have publicly spoken against a rate cut in December, pointing to persistent inflation and a robust economy. Collins highlighted the difficulties of setting policy when reliable data is lacking,

to maintain current rates for an extended period amid significant uncertainty. Bostic also expressed worries about inflation, cautioning that businesses are planning price increases in 2026, indicating ongoing inflationary challenges. Their perspectives differ from those of officials like Fed Governor Stephen Miran, who believe that the recent inflation surges are temporary and that rate reductions are still needed to support economic growth .

Market volatility has increased as the Fed’s lack of consensus leaves investors uncertain. The CME FedWatch Tool

of a 25-basis-point rate cut in December, with the possibility of a pause until 2026. Financial sector stocks have mirrored this instability, amid the ongoing unpredictability. Meanwhile, the minutes from the FOMC’s October meeting, , may provide more insight into the committee’s differing viewpoints.

The wider economic effects of the shutdown continue to be felt.

that the shutdown will reduce fourth-quarter economic growth by 1.5 percentage points, due to its disruption of government functions and data reporting. The delay in official economic releases has also forced private organizations to attempt to fill the information gap, though the reliability of their data is uncertain. The Fed’s upcoming rate decision will not only steer monetary policy but also affect consumer borrowing expenses, in home equity loan rates following previous rate cuts.

As the Fed maneuvers through these challenges, its December meeting will be a crucial test of its ability to manage inflation while supporting economic stability. The results of this meeting could influence the direction for 2026, especially as Fed Chair Jerome Powell’s term is set to end in May 2026

.